2 KUTAFIN UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW Volume 2 KUTAFIN UNIVERSITY Оctober 2016 Antokolskaja Maria (Netherlands, VU University Amsterdam) Kochenov Dimitry (Netherlands, University of Groningen) Bowring Bill (England, Birkbeck, University of London) Kutafin Dmitry (Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) Butler William (USA, Pennsylvania State University) Pashin Sergey (Russia, Higher School of Economics) Editors-in-Chief Olga Shevchenko (Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) Paul Kalinichenko (Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) Editorial Board Team Alebastrova Irina (Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) Zakharova Larissa (Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) Zaikin Sergey (Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) Lyutov Nikita (Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) Truong Tu Phuoc (Vietnam, Ho Chi Minh City University of Law) Golovina Natalia (Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) Senior Editorial Council Finnis John (Australia, University College, Oxford) Smit Paul (South Africa, University of Pretoria) Joensen Vagn (Denmark, President of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda) Tran Viet Dung (Vietnam, Ho Chi Minh City University) Klein Eckart (Germany, University of Potsdam) LAW REVIEW Volume I (September 2014) Issue 1 Issue 2(6) Frequency two issues per year Contacts www.kulawr.ru http://msal.ru/en/content/Kulawr/ info@kulawr.ru +7 (499) 244-85-55 +7 (499) 244-86-54 KULawR always welcomes new authors and sponsors www Publisher Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL) 9 Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya str., Moscow, Russia, 123995 http://msal.ru/en/ msal@msal.ru +7 (499) 244-85-55 +7 (499) 244-86-54 The opinions expressed in submissions do not necessarily reflect the position of the Editorial Body and Council. <...> Any part of this journal may not be published elsewhere without the written consent of the publisher VIII BRIEF TABLE OF CONTENTS Welcome Note .206 SELECTED SPEECHES The Brazilian <...>
Kutafin_University_Law_Review_(KULawR)_№2_2016.pdf
2
KUTAFIN UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW
Volume 2
KUTAFIN UNIVERSITY
Оctober 2016
Antokolskaja Maria
(Netherlands, VU University Amsterdam)
Kochenov Dimitry
(Netherlands, University of Groningen)
Bowring Bill
(England, Birkbeck, University of London)
Kutafin Dmitry
(Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Butler William
(USA, Pennsylvania State University)
Pashin Sergey
(Russia, Higher School of Economics)
Editors-in-Chief
Olga Shevchenko
(Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Paul Kalinichenko
(Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Editorial Board Team
Alebastrova Irina
(Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Zakharova Larissa
(Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Zaikin Sergey
(Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Lyutov Nikita
(Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Truong Tu Phuoc
(Vietnam, Ho Chi Minh City University of Law)
Golovina Natalia
(Russia, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Senior Editorial Council
Finnis John
(Australia, University College, Oxford)
Smit Paul
(South Africa, University of Pretoria)
Joensen Vagn
(Denmark, President of the International Criminal
Tribunal for Rwanda)
Tran Viet Dung
(Vietnam, Ho Chi Minh City University)
Klein Eckart
(Germany, University of Potsdam)
LAW REVIEW
Volume I (September 2014) Issue 1
Issue 2(6)
Frequency
two issues per year
Contacts
www.kulawr.ru
http://msal.ru/en/content/Kulawr/
info@kulawr.ru
+7 (499) 244-85-55
+7 (499) 244-86-54
KULawR always welcomes new
authors and sponsors
www
Publisher
Kutafin Moscow
State Law University (MSAL)
9 Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya str.,
Moscow, Russia, 123995
http://msal.ru/en/
msal@msal.ru
+7 (499) 244-85-55
+7 (499) 244-86-54
The opinions expressed in
submissions do not necessarily
reflect the position of the
Editorial Body and Council.
All rights reserved.
Any part of this journal may not
be published elsewhere without
the written consent of the
publisher
Стр.1
VIII
BRIEF TABLE OF CONTENTS
Welcome Note ..........................................................................................................206
SELECTED SPEECHES
The Brazilian National Council of Justice: Social and Environmental
Responsibility of the Brazilian Judiciary Branch
Article by Andre Ramos Tavares (Brazil) .................................................................207
PRESSING ISSUES OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Glasnost in the Security Council: The Value of Transparency
Article by Devika Hovell (The United Kingdom) .....................................................222
LEGAL PROFESSION ABROAD
An Introduction to State Administrative Agencies in Vietnam
Article by Truong Tu Phuoc (Vietnam) ....................................................................254
Opportunities and Threats of Concentration
of Local Services Provision in Hungary
Article by István Hoffman (Hungary) ......................................................................269
LEGAL PROFESSION ABROAD OR THE HISTORY OF LAW
The Legal Status of a Judge in the Kingdom of Poland
Article by dr Anna Korzeniewska-Lasota (Poland) ..................................................290
THE UNION OF HISTORY AND MODERNITY IN LAW
PRACTICING AND MAKING
Development of the Russian Legislation in the Field of Protection
of Intellectual Rights Assets and Equivalent Means
of Individualization
Article by Valeria Lambina (Russian Federation) ...................................................301
How to Design Criminal Law in the XXI Century
Article by Sakari Melander (Finland) .......................................................................311
LEGAL REGULATION OF ECONOMIC RELATIONSHIPS:
THEORY AND PRACTICE
Economic Principles of Responsibility
Article by Sergey Bortnikov (Russian Federation) ..................................................320
Counter Guarantee: Legal Regulation and Problems of Application
by Russian Banks
Article by Diana Alexeeva (Russian Federation)
and Irina Mikheeva (Russian Federation) ...............................................................331
Budgetary Institutions in the Context of Budget Reform in Russia
Article by Ekaterina Kudryashova (Russian Federation) ........................................347
www.kulawr.ru
Volume 2 Оctober 2016 Issue 2(6)
Стр.2
BRIEF TABLE OF CONTENTS
RUSSIAN SEASONS IN THE LIFE OF THE LEGAL COMMUNITY
Overview of the Third Moscow Legal Forum
Article by Olga Shevchenko (Russian Federation) ..................................................358
The Future of International Law
Article by Larissa Zakharova (Russian Federation) ................................................366
Highlights of the Vi St. Petersburg International Legal Forum
Article by Larissa Zakharova (Russian Federation) ................................................371
Best International Practices of Higher Law Education
Article by Olga Shevchenko (Russian Federation) ..................................................376
Civic Education is the Best Practice
Article by Nicholas W. Allard (United States) .........................................................382
Federal Chamber of Advocates of the Russian Federation
Article by William C. Hubbard (United States) .......................................................388
Questions of Development of Laws on Administrative Proceeding
in the Russian Federation
Article by Vladimir Pligin (Russian Federation)......................................................396
Private Autonomy and Principle of Subsidiarity
Article by Enrico del Prato (Italy) ............................................................................415
IX
Volume 2 Оctober 2016 Issue 2(6)
www.kulawr.ru
Стр.3
X
DETAILED TABLE OF CONTENTS
Welcome Note ...........................................................................................................206
SELECTED SPEECHES
The Brazilian National Council of Justice: Social and Environmental
Responsibility of the Brazilian Judiciary Branch
Article by Andre Ramos Tavares (Brazil) .................................................................207
I.
II.
III. What is the Environmental Responsibility
of the Administrative Area of the Judiciary Branch?............................. 213
(1) Sustainable Development ................................................................. 215
(2) Integrated Management of Environmental Measures .................... 216
(3) NCJ Advisory’s Measures and the 1St Social
and Environmental Seminar of the Brazilian
Judiciary Branch ............................................................................... 217
(4) Final Issues to be Addressed and Some Examples
of Innovative Solutions ..................................................................... 218
IV. Conclusions ..............................................................................................219
Bibliography ......................................................................................................220
PRESSING ISSUES OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Glasnost in the Security Council: The Value of Transparency
Article By Devika Hovell (The United Kingdom) ....................................................222
I.
Introduction .............................................................................................223
II. The ‘Why’ of Transparency ......................................................................225
A. Legitimacy, the Publicity Principle
and the un Security Council .............................................................228
B. Understanding Security Council Authority ..................................... 231
i. The Purposive Justification: Reflexivity to Reason .........................234
ii. The Polity Justification: Reflexivity to Public .................................236
iii. The Princely Justification: Reflexivity to Power.............................. 241
III. The Who, What When and How of Transparency:
Transparency in Security Council Sanctions Decision-Making .............244
A. The ‘Who’ of Transparency: Relationship to Target .......................245
B. The ‘What’ of Transparency: Relationship to Justification ............245
C. The ‘When’ of Transparency: Relationship to Time ....................... 247
D. The ‘How’ of Transparency: Relationship To Expertise .................248
IV. Conclusion ................................................................................................248
Bibliography ......................................................................................................249
www.kulawr.ru
Volume 2 Оctober 2016 Issue 2(6)
The Brazilian Context and The Functions
of the National Council of Justice ...........................................................208
Social Rights and the Case of the Right to Health .................................209
Стр.4
DETAILED TABLE OF CONTENTS
LEGAL PROFESSION ABROAD
An Introduction to State Administrative Agencies in Vietnam
Article By Truong Tu Phuoc (Vietnam) ....................................................................254
I.
Introduction .............................................................................................255
II. The Government ......................................................................................256
III. Ministries and Ministry-Level Agencies .................................................259
IV. The People’s Committee ..........................................................................261
V.
VII. Conclusion ................................................................................................267
Bibliography ......................................................................................................267
Opportunities and Threats of Concentration of Local Services
Provision in Hungary
Article by István Hoffman (Hungary) ......................................................................269
I.
Introduction .............................................................................................271
II. The Frameworks of the Hungarian Local Public
Service Delivery System...........................................................................272
II.1. The Starting Point: Concentration and Centralization
in the Area of the Soviet Type Administration ................................272
II.2. The Strongly Decentralized Model of the
Act Lxv of 1990 on the Local Self-Governments ............................ 272
III. The Time of Concentration in the Light of the European
Tendencies and the Reforms in Hungary ...............................................274
III.1. A the Oretical Outlook: Concentration,
Centralization and Decentralization ..............................................274
III.2. A European Outlook: Concentration Tendencies
in the Public Service Provision in Europe .....................................275
III.3. Concentration of the Provision of Municipal
Public Services In Hungary ............................................................ 279
IV. After the Economic Crisis: The Age of Recentralization ........................282
IV.1. The Transformation of the Frameworks of the
Hungarian System After the Economic Crisis ...............................282
IV.2. Changes of The Provision of Local
Public Services After 2010 .............................................................284
Conclusion ................................................................................................286
Bibliography ......................................................................................................289
V.
Volume 2 Оctober 2016 Issue 2(6)
www.kulawr.ru
XI
Specialized Agencies of the People’s Committee ....................................263
VI. Some Practical Issues of State Administrative Agencies
in Vietnam ................................................................................................265
Стр.5
XII
KUTAFIN UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW
THE HISTORY OF LAW
The Legal Status of a Judge in the Kingdomы of Poland
Article by Anna Korzeniewska-Lasota (Poland) ......................................................290
I.
Constitutional Period ............................................................................... 291
II. The period between the uprisings ........................................................... 293
III. The Period After the January Uprising ..................................................297
VI. Conclusion ................................................................................................299
Bibliography ......................................................................................................300
THE UNION OF HISTORY AND MODERNITY
IN MAKING AND IMPLEMENTING LAW
Development of the Russian Legislation in the Field of Protection
of Intellectual Rights Assets and Equivalent Means
of Individualization
Article by Valeria Lambina (Russian Federation) ...................................................301
Introduction ......................................................................................................302
I.
Pre_revolutionary Period ........................................................................303
I.1. Means of Individualization ...............................................................303
II. The Soviet Period .....................................................................................304
III. The Post_soviet Period ............................................................................307
III.1. Changes in the Legislation ............................................................. 307
III.2. Intellectual Property Rights Protection .........................................307
III.3. Establishment of the Court for Intellectual Property Rights .......308
III.4. Statistics of Cases Considered by the Court for Intellectual
Property Rights as of the End of May 2014 ..................................309
IV. Conclusion ................................................................................................309
Bibliography ......................................................................................................310
How to Design Criminal Law in the XXI Century
Article by Sakari Melander (Finland) .......................................................................311
I.
Introduction .............................................................................................312
II. From Offensive Criminal Law to Proactive Criminal Law ..................... 313
III. Counterforces to Proactive Use of Criminal Law ................................... 316
IV. Conclusion ................................................................................................318
Bibliography ......................................................................................................319
LEGAL REGULATION OF ECONOMIC RELATIONSHIPS:
THEORY AND PRACTICE
Economic Principles of Responsibility
Article by Sergey Bortnikov (Russian Federation) ..................................................320
www.kulawr.ru
Volume 2 Оctober 2016 Issue 2(6)
Стр.6
DETAILED TABLE OF CONTENTS
Counter Guarantee: Legal Regulation and Problems of Application
by Russian Banks
Article by Diana Alexeeva (Russian Federation)
and Irina Mikheeva (Russian Federation) ...............................................................331
I.
Introduction .............................................................................................332
II. The Concept and Legal Regulation of a Counter Guarantee ................. 333
III. The Form of a Counter Guarantee .......................................................... 337
IV. An Agreement Between a Guarantor and a Principal
for Execution of Which a Guarantee is Issued .......................................338
V.
Legal Problems of Identification of a Proper Debtor Under
a Counter Guarantee ................................................................................340
VI. Legal Risks in Case of Issuing a Counter Guarantee in Russia .............344
VII. Conclusion ................................................................................................346
Bibliography ......................................................................................................346
Budgetary Institutions in the Context of Budget Reform in Russia
Article by Ekaterina Kudryashova (Russian Federation) ........................................347
I.
An Overview of the Budget Reform in Russia ........................................348
II. Pre-Reform Budgetary Institutions and Reasons For Changes .............349
III. The New Budgetary Institutions in Russia ............................................. 351
IV. The Problem of Performance Management in Public Sector ................ 355
V.
Conclusion ................................................................................................356
Bibliography ......................................................................................................356
RUSSIAN SEASONS IN THE LIFE OF THE LEGAL COMMUNITY
Overview of the Third Moscow Legal Forum
Article by Olga Shevchenko (Russian Federation) ..................................................358
The Future of International Law
Article by Larissa Zakharova (Russian Federation) ................................................366
Highlights of the VI St. Petersburg International Legal Forum
Article by Larissa Zakharova (Russian Federation) ................................................371
Best International Practices of Higher Law Education
Article by Olga Shevchenko (Russian Federation) ..................................................376
Civic Education is the Best Practice
Article by Nicholas W. Allard (United States) .........................................................382
Federal Chamber of Advocates of the Russian Federation
Article by William C. Hubbard (United States) .......................................................388
Questions of Development of Laws on Administrative Proceeding
in the Russian Federation
Article by Vladimir Pligin (Russian Federation)......................................................396
Private Autonomy and Principle of Subsidiarity
Article by Enrico del Prato (Italy) ............................................................................415
Volume 2 Оctober 2016 Issue 2(6)
www.kulawr.ru
XIII
Стр.7