THE MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND SCIENCE OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
KUTAFIN MOSCOW STATE LAW UNIVERSITY
Larisa I. Zakharova
INTERNATIONAL
SPORTS LAW
Textbook
for Bachelor Students
Edited by
Doctor of Science (Law), Professor,
Honoured Scholar of the Russian Federation
Kamil A. Bekyashev
Moscow
2018
Стр.1
UDC 796:34
BBC 75.4
Z-38
Electronic versions of books
at www.prospekt.org
Author:
of thLarisa I. Zakharova, PhD (Law), Associate Professor of the International Law Department
e Kutafin Moscow State Law University, member of the FIFA Appeal Committee.
Reviewer:
Victor N. Sidorov, PhD (Law), Associate Professor of the International Law Department of
the Kutafin Moscow State Law University.
Editor:
pKamil A. Bekyashev, Doctor of Science (Law), Professor of the International Law DeFartment
of the Kutafin Moscow State Law University, Honoured Scholar of the Russian
ederation.
Z-38
Larisa I. Zakharova
shInternational Sports Law: Textbook for Bachelor Students / ed. by K. A. Bekyaev.—
Moscow : Prospekt, 2018. — 240 p.
for Higher Education as applied to specialisation
ISBN 978-5-392-28461-0
The Textbook was prepared in accordance with the Federal State Educational Standard
niversity in January 2017.
th The Textbook consists of 17 chapters. They correspond to the themes of the syllabus of
nion, at the bilateral level are considered. The Author makes a corresponding distinction
e with the object, subjects, sources, special principles of lex sportiva, a set of corporate norms
40.03.01 “Jurisprudence” (Bachelor
L (degree) qualification) and the syllabus of the academic discipline “International Sports
Uaw”, approved by the International Law Department of the Kutafin Moscow State Law
pre academic discipline. In its General part, the history, object, subjects, sources, special
Uies and programs, at the regional level within the Council of Europe and the European
inciples of international sports law, the process of regulation of international sports relactions
at the universal level within the framework of the United Nations, its specialised agenlaborated
by the International Olympic Committee, the International Paralympic Committee,
international and national sports federations. Special attention is paid to the study
of ways of resolving sports disputes through arbitration and appeal proceedings in the Court
of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), by means of judicial proceedings in the European Court of
Human Rights (ECtHR) and the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU).
The Special Part of the Textbook identifies problem areas that require additional efforts
v to implement international legal and corporate regulations: the use of doping in sport,
oiolence and hooligan behaviour of spectators and fans, environmental protection when
narganising international sports competitions, economic crimes and discrimination in interof
inttional sports, protection of property rights with regard to television and radio broadcasts
ernational sports competitions, the use of Olympic symbols, countering threats to a
Pation institutions, practicing lawyers, staff members of organizations of the Olympic and
t aralympic movements, as well as for all those whose academic interests and practical acivities
are connected with international law, sports law and lex sportivа.
UDC 796:34
BBC 75.4
ISBN 978-5-392-28461-0
©© Захарова Л. И., 2018
ООО «Проспект», 2018
healthy lifestyle.
International instruments and acts of the Russian legislation are as of May 2018.
c The Textbook will be of interest for Bachelor students of law, lecturers of higher edu
Стр.2
CONTENTS
Introduction ........................................................................................................................10
Abbreviations .....................................................................................................................12
GENERAL PART
Chapter 1. OBJECT OF REGULATION IN INTERNATIONAL
SPORTS LAW AND LEX SPORTIVА. FORMATION
OF THE OLYMPIC AND PARALYMPIC MOVEMENT .............14
1.1. Notion and the Object of the Legal Regulation
in International Sports Law .......................................................................14
1.2. Place of the Norms Regulating International Sports Relations
in the Legal System. The Notion of Lex Sportivа ..............................18
1.3. The Formation of the Modern Olympic and the Paralympic
Movement. The Formation of Lex Olympica ........................................21
Control Questions and Tasks ........................................................................................28
Bibliography .......................................................................................................................28
Chapter 2. SUBJECTS OF INTERNATIONAL SPORTS LAW ......................29
2.1. Subjects of International Sports Law: Concept, Types ......................29
2.2. The International Personality of States .................................................31
2.3. The International Personality of International Governmental
Organizations .................................................................................................32
Control Questions and Tasks ........................................................................................34
Bibliography and Normative Acts ...............................................................................34
Chapter 3. SOURCES OF INTERNATIONAL SPORTS LAW .......................35
3.1. Sources of International Sports Law: Concept and Types................35
3.2. International Treaties as a Source of International Sports Law .... 37
Стр.3
4
Contents
3.3. International Legal Customs as a Source of International
Sports Law .......................................................................................................40
3.4. Resolutions of International Governmental Organizations
as a Source of International Sports Law ...............................................41
3.5. Unilateral Acts of States as a Source of International
Sports Law .......................................................................................................44
3.6. Decisions of International Non-Governmental Organizations
of the Olympic Movement as a Source of Lex Sportiva ...................46
3.7. Jurisprudence of International Courts and Arbitral Tribunals
as a Subsidiary Means for Determining Rules of International
Sports Law and Lex Sportivа ..................................................................... 47
Control Questions and Tasks ........................................................................................48
Bibliography and Normative Acts ...............................................................................49
Chapter 4. SPECIAL PRINCIPLES OF INTERNATIONAL
SPORTS LAW ...........................................................................................50
4.1. The Concept and Classifi cation of Special Principles
of International Sports Law .......................................................................50
4.2. The Content and Normative Consolidation of Special
Principles of International Sports Law ..................................................51
4.3. The Concept, Scope and Normative Consolidation of Special
Principles of Corporate Regulation of Sports Activities
(lex sportiva) ...................................................................................................53
Control Questions and Tasks ........................................................................................56
Bibliography and Normative Acts ..............................................................................56
Chapter 5. REGULATION OF INTERNATIONAL SPORTS
RELATIONS AT THE UNIVERSAL LEVEL
IN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE UNITED NATIONS
SPECIALIZED AGENCIES AND PROGRAMMES .....................57
5.1. The Role of the UN Bodies in Regulating the Organization
of International Sports Activities............................................................. 57
5.2. The Activities of UNESCO in the Field of Physical Education
and Sport and Its Cooperation with the IOC .......................................62
5.3. The Interaction between UNEP and the IOC.
Agenda 21 of the Olympic Movement of 1999 ..................................64
5.4. The Cooperation of WIPO and the IOC in the Protection
of the Olympic Symbol ................................................................................66
Стр.4
Contents
5
5.5. Cooperation of WHO and the IOC in Promoting
a Healthy Lifestyle ........................................................................................70
Control Questions and Tasks ........................................................................................71
Bibliography and Normative Acts ...............................................................................72
Chapter 6. REGULATION OF INTERNATIONAL SPORTS
RELATIONS AT THE UNIVERSAL LEVEL WITHIN
THE ORGANIZATIONS OF THE OLYMPIC
AND PARALYMPIC MOVEMENTS ..................................................73
6.1. Legal Status of International Non-Governmental
Organizations of the Olympic Movement .............................................73
6.2. The IOC Olympic Charter (in force as from 15 September
2017) – the Basis of Lex Olympica. Its Features,
Structure, Content ........................................................................................75
6.3. Subjects of Corporate Relations in the Field of Sports ....................85
6.3.1. The International Olympic Committee (IOC):
the Structure, Mandate, Main Directions of Activities ...........85
6.3.2. International Sports Federations for Olympic Sports ...........93
6.3.3. The International Paralympic Committee (IPC):
the Structure, Mandate, Main Directions of Activities ........ 101
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 116
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 116
Chapter 7. ACTIVITIES OF THE COURT OF ARBITRATION
FOR SPORT (CAS) ................................................................................ 118
7.1. The Creation of CAS and National Sport Arbitration
Tribunal .......................................................................................................... 118
7.2. Competence of the International Council of Arbitration
for Sport. ........................................................................................................ 121
7.3. The Competence of the CAS: Arbitration and Mediation
in the Settlement of Sport Disputes ................................................... 122
7.4. Requirements for CAS Arbitrators .......................................................... 123
7.5. General Characteristics of Arbitration
and Appeal Proceedings in CAS ............................................................ 124
7.6. Major Categories of Cases before CAS ..................................................127
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 133
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 133
Стр.5
6
Contents
Chapter 8. REGULATION OF INTERNATIONAL SPORTS
RELATIONS AT THE REGIONAL LEVEL
IN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE COUNCIL
OF EUROPE AND THE EUROPEAN UNION ............................ 134
8.1. The Activities of the Council of Europe in the elaboration
of International Instruments in the Field of Sport ......................... 134
8.2. The Adoption of Non-Binding Acts in the Field of Sports
at the Council of Europe. Ministerial Conferences on Sports ......137
8.3. The Competence of the European Union (EU)
in the Field of Sports ................................................................................ 138
8.4. Judicial Practice in the Resolution of Sports Disputes in the
European Court of Human Rights and the Court of Justice
of the European Union (Court of Justice of the European
Communities) ............................................................................................... 142
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 145
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 145
Chapter 9. REGULATION OF INTERNATIONAL SPORTS
RELATIONS AT THE BILATERAL LEVEL .................................. 147
9.1. The Concept and Types of Bilateral Treaties and Agreements
on Sport, Tourism, Youth Policy ..............................................................147
9.2. The Content of Bilateral Agreements of the Russian
Federation in the Field of Sports ......................................................... 148
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 152
Bibliography and Normative Acts ........................................................................... 153
SPECIAL PART
Chapter 10. INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION IN FIGHTING
AGAINST DOPING IN SPORT ........................................................ 154
10.1. The History of the Emergence of Doping and the Fight
Against it Within the Framework of the Olympic
Movement .................................................................................................... 154
10.2. The World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA): its Legal Status,
Competence, the 2003 World Anti-Doping Code
(as amended on 1 January 2015) ......................................................... 155
10.3. The 2005 UNESCO International Convention against Doping
in Sport: its Structure, Contents, and a Control
Mechanism .................................................................................................. 161
Стр.6
Contents
7
10.4. Fight Against Doping Within the Council of Europe.
The 1989 Anti-Doping Convention of the Council
of Europe and its 2002 Additional Protocol .................................... 165
10.5. The Problem of Doping in Russian Sports........................................ 166
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 171
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 171
Chapter 11. THE PROBLEM OF VIOLENCE AND HOOLIGAN
BEHAVIOUR OF FANS DURING INTERNATIONAL
SPORTS EVENTS ............................................................................... 172
11.1. The European Convention on Spectator Violence and
Misbehaviour at Sports Events and in Particular at Football
Matches of 1985: its Structure, Contents, and a Control
Mechanism .................................................................................................. 172
11.2. The Council of Europe Convention on an Integrated
Safety, Security and Service Approach at Football Matches
and Other Sports Events of 2016: its Structure, Contents,
and a Control Mechanism ...................................................................... 175
11.3. Acts of Corporate Regulation of Organizations
of the Olympic Movement Prohibiting Violence
and Hooligan Behaviour of Supporters ............................................ 179
11.4. Participation of the Russian Federation in Resolving
the Problem of Violence and Hooligan Behaviour
of Sports Fans ............................................................................................ 181
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 183
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 184
Chapter 12. ECOLOGICAL ASPECTS OF ORGANIZING
INTERNATIONAL SPORTS COMPETITIONS....................... 185
12.1. Environmental Protection in the Process of Sports
Activities Development .......................................................................... 185
12.2. 1999 Olympic Movement’s Agenda 21 as a Result
of Cooperation Between the UN Environment Programme
(UNEP) and the IOC Sport and Environment Commission ......... 186
12.3. Environmental Protection within the Olympic Movement ........ 192
12.4. Ecological and Legal Aspects of Organising the Olympic
Games in Sochi in 2014 and the World Cup in 2018 ................... 195
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 199
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 199
Стр.7
8
Contents
Chapter 13. ECONOMIC CRIMES IN SPORT .................................................. 201
13.1. Corruption as the Violation of the Principle of Fair Play ........... 201
13.2. Fight Against Economic Crimes in Sport within the UN
Framework ................................................................................................... 202
13.3. Fight Against Corruption Within the Council of Europe ............. 203
13.4. Anti-Corruption Legislation of the Russian Federation .............. 205
Control Questions and Tasks ......................................................................................207
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 208
Chapter 14. COMBATING DISCRIMINATION
IN INTERNATIONAL SPORT .......................................................... 209
14.1. Prohibition of Any Form of Discrimination in International
Law. International legal Acts Prohibiting Political, Religious,
Racial Discrimination in Sport ............................................................. 209
14.2. Prohibition of Any Form of Discrimination in Lex Sportiva.
Recommendation 14 of the “Olympic Agenda-2020” .................. 212
14.3. Fair Play Movement: its History, Purposes, and Structure .......... 218
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 219
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 219
Chapter 15. PROBLEMS OF PROTECTION OF PROPERTY RIGHTS
TO TELEVISION AND RADIO BROADCASTING
OF INTERNATIONAL SPORTS COMPETITIONS ................ 221
15.1. International Legal Acts on the Protection of Related
Rights of Broadcasting Organizations ............................................. 221
15.2. Formation of Protection of the Rights to Television
and Radio Broadcasting of International Sports Competitions
Within the Framework of the Olympic Movement ........................ 223
15.3. Provisions of the Olympic Charter Concerning Protection
of Rights to Television and Radio Broadcasting
of International Sports Competitions ................................................ 225
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 226
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................ 226
Chapter 16. LEGAL ISSUES OF THE USE OF OLYMPIC SYMBOLS ... 228
16.1. The Nairobi Treaty of the World Intellectual Property
Organization (WIPO) on the Protection of the Olympic
Symbol of 26 September 1981: its Structure, Content,
and Signifi cance ........................................................................................ 228
Стр.8
Contents
9
16.2. The IOC Exclusive Rights to Olympic Property. Sponsorship
and Licensing Agreements .................................................................... 230
16.3. Legal Issues of Using Olympic Symbols in Preparation
for the Olympic Games in Sochi in 2014.......................................... 232
Control Questions and Tasks ..................................................................................... 233
Bibliography and Normative Acts ........................................................................... 233
Chapter 17. THE FIGHT OF THE WHO AND THE IOC AGAINST
THREATS TO HEALTHY LIFESTYLE ......................................... 234
17.1. The WHO and IOC Efforts to Control Tobacco ................................ 234
17.2. The WHO Global Strategy on Diet, Physical Activity
and Health of 2004: its Structure, Content,
and Signifi cance ........................................................................................ 235
17.3. Memorandum of Understanding Between the WHO
and the IOC to Promote Healthy Lifestyle of 2010:
its Content, Controlling Body, the Main Areas of Joint
Activities ...................................................................................................... 236
Control Questions and Tasks ......................................................................................237
Bibliography and Normative Acts ............................................................................237
Стр.9